Year 11 - Merchant of Venice Discussion

Class Discussion and brain storming for Thursday 27th of March:

Since we have watched the movie and read the play let us discuss the social under currents and themes we observed.

From the viewing of ‘The Merchant of Venice’

The new Merchant of Venice movie is one of my favorite Shakespeare adaptations, up there with Orson Welles and Baz Luhrmann (yes, really). Here is a quick interpretation, it is full of spoilers but if you really don't know the plot they will more likely help you than ruin the fun...

1. There is textual evidence that Shakespeare was anti-Semitic, but anti-Semitism is not the primary point of the plot.

2. Shakespeare uses stereotypes about Jews to mock his audience and to mock anti-Semites. Most of all he is pointing the joke back in the faces of the bigots. "Who is the merchant and who is the Jew?" is one of the central lines of the text. And it is no accident that the play is named after the merchant, not after Shylock.

3. Shakespeare shows most of the play's Christians to be mean, hypocritical, and full of lies. They have every bad quality that they accuse the Jews of having, and more. This is a very dark comedy.

4. The stories concerning the rings should be followed carefully. The film mentions briefly (too briefly, perhaps) that Shylock treasured and kept the ring from his wife. Compare this to how the Christians treat their rings.